The most common practice for
auditing compliance is a ‘Find it and Fix it’ cycle, where the
auditor assesses a field situation as it exists during an audit. The
auditor will check the work site for issues identified against a set
of protocols for the purpose of compliance with government
regulations, company policies or a mixture of both.
During the assessment, the
auditor typically walks a site with a notepad and pencil taking
notes of field observations not in compliance with their protocol.
Following the assessment, the auditor shares the findings with the
responsible safety person.
Sometimes the process of
reporting findings can take weeks. The cycle is repeated when the
auditor comes back at some later time to check the site again. The
‘Find & Fix’ audit cycle works, but only to a point. The difficult
part comes next.
What
happens with that inspection form or accident investigation
report after it is completed? It is likely reviewed by a few people,
perhaps transcribed into electronic form by
a data entry clerk (where data entry errors may enter the
equation) and filed away someplace for legal and compliance reasons,
rarely (if ever) to be seen again.
Filing data away in a drawer is
better than nothing because it shows some documentation of findings,
but that is where the benefits end. What happens when the auditor is
asked to compile year long data from the findings? How do you
evaluate data specific to a situation? The paper method of
recordkeeping makes compiling field data into a report an enormous
task.
If data is collected and stored
electronically, accessing and reporting on it becomes very easy.
Questions like, “How many HAZCOM issues were at the North Side plant
last year?” or “How many overdue action items does Dave in
maintenance have?” can be answered by simply making a request of
your data.
Electronic Data Capture
Handheld technology allows the
auditor to capture field data electronically at the point of
discovery and can eliminate the problem of having to manually
compile information.
Using a PDA, data entered in the
field can be utilized in many ways. Some safety programs written for
PDAs allow you to print reports immediately from the handheld
device. Others require the data to first be uploaded to a desktop
computer. Either way, the reports generated can include photos and
reference information along with field comments. These reports
support the auditor’s findings and take away any argument about
grams written specifically for safety professionals offer reference
information (i.e. OSHA 1910 Regulations) linked directly to the
questions being asked. A PDA’s large memory capacity allows
reference materials to be loaded and accessed from the PDA in the
field. Reference materials can be included on the reports or
accessed by the auditor for clarification
Reporting, Communication and
Learning
Perhaps the greatest benefit of
capturing data electronically is the ability to create reports with
ease. Since data is collected electronically and stored in a
database, it is always available for easy retrieval. In great
contrast to compiling data from paper audits, generating reports is
as simple as making a request to the database for the information
you want.
Not only is reporting easier but
it can serve more needs. Certain reports can serve as a means of
internal communication. They can be designed to be sent updated and
returned. Follow up actions can be assigned and sent
electronically to those who need them. Reports on action status can
be sent as reminders to each assignee.
Reports can be utilized as a
learning tool as well. Follow up reports can show the photo evidence
from the point of discovery and cite the relevant regulatory
reference.
Positive observations can be
shown as well, giving positive feedback to those employees who have
met or exceeded expectations. The reports should become a learning
tool for those who receive them and contribute to continued
improvement.
Looking Forward
The handheld computer market is
evolving and converging with the cell phone market. Differences
between cell phones and PDAs are becoming less recognizable.
Today’s business world continues
to demand faster response times and constant connectivity.
Manufacturers have responded and we are seeing the emergence of
hybrid devices that incorporate handheld computer capability with
cellular technology in the form of smart phones and pocket PC
phones.
PDA and cell phone manufacturers
are utilizing more powerful operating systems, increasing memory
capacity, and recognizing more cellular services. Cellular providers
are supporting more devices, offering better internet access and
email services. The next generation devices will eliminate the need
to carry multiple devices. They will likely have a camera, a
keyboard, and GPS with all the power of a portable computer and the
convenience of a cell phone.
If auditors would better utilize
handheld technology, the audit cycle could be streamlined to serve a
Results Analysis audit cycle where continuous improvement could be
realized.
FSM